Jon Moxley Defeats Katsuyori Shibata in Controversial AEW Dynamite Match, Sparking Fan Backlash

On the April 9, 2025, episode of AEW Dynamite, Jon Moxley faced Katsuyori Shibata in a match that left fans divided and frustrated. The bout, which opened the show, saw Moxley secure victory by making Shibata pass out in a rear choke—a finish that came unexpectedly early and left many questioning AEW's booking decisions.

The Match and Its Reception Shibata, a highly respected wrestler with a storied career in Japan, showcased his technical prowess throughout the match. Despite his strong performance, the brevity of the contest and its outcome drew widespread criticism from fans. Many felt that Shibata deserved more time to shine against Moxley, who is both AEW World Champion and newly appointed Interim Trios Champion following PAC's injury. The abrupt finish, which included Moxley resorting to an eye gouge to gain the upper hand, further fueled disappointment among viewers who believed Shibata was being underutilized.

Fan Reactions and Booking Concerns Discussions erupted across social media and wrestling forums, with fans expressing frustration over Shibata's frequent losses in AEW. Critics argued that his talent and legacy were not being adequately respected by the promotion. This sentiment echoes broader concerns about AEW's booking decisions under Tony Khan, where perceived mismanagement of top-tier talent has become a recurring theme.

The timing of this match also raised eyebrows as it followed AEW Dynasty's controversial ending, leaving fans yearning for a stronger start to Dynamite. Instead, the disjointed pacing of the show compounded dissatisfaction with how Shibata's role was handled.

Implications for AEW While Moxley's victory solidifies his dominance as a double champion heading into his upcoming title defenses, the fallout from this match highlights growing unease among AEW's fanbase regarding its creative direction. As Moxley prepares to defend both titles against formidable opponents like Samoa Joe and Hook alongside Shibata next week, AEW faces mounting pressure to address these criticisms and deliver compelling storylines that honor its roster's diverse talents.

The controversy surrounding Shibata’s treatment serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between storytelling and respecting veteran performers—a balance AEW must navigate carefully to maintain its reputation as a wrestling haven for both established stars and rising talent.