Paul Pogba and the Burden of Expectation: Reassessing One of Football’s Most Misunderstood Talents

---

A Career Defined by Brilliance and Controversy

Few players in modern football have sparked as much debate as Paul Pogba. Once heralded as a generational talent capable of reshaping midfield play, Pogba’s career has unfolded under an unforgiving spotlight. From the heights of winning the FIFA World Cup with France in 2018 to enduring persistent injuries and relentless scrutiny at Manchester United, his journey embodies both the glory and the hardship that come with global fame in sport.

Pogba emerged from the famed Manchester United academy but left for Juventus as a teenager due to limited first-team opportunities. His rise in Italy was meteoric. At Juventus, he became the heartbeat of a dominant midfield, blending flair, power, and intelligence in a way that set him apart from his contemporaries. The combination of technical precision, passing vision, and elegant athleticism earned him comparisons to legends of the game and established him as one of Europe’s most valuable players.

The Return to Manchester United

When Pogba returned to Manchester United in 2016 for what was then a world-record transfer fee, expectations soared. The move symbolized more than just a reunion; it was an attempt to restore the club’s dominance during a challenging post-Ferguson era. Pogba’s presence was meant to define a new chapter for the Red Devils: attractive, attacking football anchored by a dynamic midfield general.

However, the reality proved far more complex. While Pogba occasionally demonstrated his immense talent—most notably in the 2017 Europa League final and several commanding performances in the Premier League—he became a lightning rod for criticism. Every misplaced pass or tactical disagreement seemed magnified. Critics questioned his consistency, commitment, and even his hairstyle choices. Fans and pundits debated whether he fit the club’s identity or if he was a luxury player ill-suited to the intensity of English football.

Racial Bias and Cultural Misunderstanding

Beneath the football analysis, many observers have pointed to deeper, more uncomfortable truths about the nature of Pogba’s treatment by fans and media. As a confident, outspoken Black athlete who embraced self-expression—whether through fashion, faith, or personality—Pogba often faced a level of scrutiny that similar players did not.

Cultural expression in sport has long been a point of tension, especially in Europe, where a traditionalist fan culture can sometimes clash with modern forms of identity. Pogba’s flair, his passion for music, and his openness about faith became unfairly conflated with a perceived lack of discipline or seriousness. The contrast between how he was praised for exuberance when performing well but condemned for the same traits during downturns revealed an unequal standard that cannot be ignored.

Several former players and commentators have since argued that Pogba became a scapegoat—a vessel through which frustrations about Manchester United’s broader struggles were channeled. In this view, the criticism often exceeded what was warranted by performance alone.

The Weight of Expectations

The financial and symbolic weight of Pogba’s transfer fee amplified every aspect of his career. At a club used to icons like Roy Keane and Paul Scholes, Pogba was expected not only to dominate games but to embody leadership and consistency amid structural instability. Managerial turnover, tactical confusion, and an evolving Premier League pace created an environment in which no single player could thrive fully.

When Pogba excelled—such as during Ole Gunnar Solskjær’s early tenure—he did so spectacularly. Yet long stretches of injury and fluctuating fortune created a narrative of unfulfilled potential. What many fans perceived as inconsistency could just as easily be seen as a reflection of a chaotic club environment and unrealistic public demand.

Redemption in Blue: World Cup Glory

The 2018 FIFA World Cup offered a contrasting chapter. Wearing the French national colors, Pogba showcased precisely the qualities that had once made him a global sensation. His maturity, tactical awareness, and leadership anchored a team that balanced flair with discipline. In the final against Croatia, Pogba’s composed finish helped secure France’s second world title, confirming his ability to deliver on football’s greatest stage.

That summer solidified his reputation internationally but also complicated perceptions at home. Supporters questioned why the version of Pogba that thrived for France could not always do the same at Manchester United. The answer, as many professionals attest, lies in context. The French squad’s stability, managerial clarity, and defined midfield roles allowed Pogba to flourish. Club-level volatility, by contrast, often left him isolated or misused.

Comparing Regional Treatment and Media Narratives

Across Europe, treatment of creative midfielders varies dramatically. In countries like Spain or Italy, players celebrated for artistry—such as Andrea Pirlo or Luka Modrić—tend to receive more patience and appreciation. England’s often more results-driven football culture can blur nuance, focusing on output metrics rather than stylistic contributions.

In Italy, Pogba’s flair was interpreted as innovation; in England, too often, it was presented as extravagance. French media, meanwhile, walked a line between admiration and critique, frequently portraying him as a symbol of modern multicultural France. That difference in narrative framing reveals how cultural context shapes the public perception of athletes and how narratives can either elevate or diminish reputations regardless of underlying performance data.

Injuries and the Decline of Momentum

From 2019 onward, Pogba’s career trajectory became increasingly hampered by injuries and off-field turmoil. Recurring ankle and knee problems reduced his availability, while public disagreements with successive managers—most notably Jose Mourinho—dominateds. The effect was cumulative: Pogba moved from being the face of Manchester United’s resurgence to a misunderstood figure burdened with unmet expectations.

His return to Juventus in 2022 seemed a chance at renewal, a circle closing where it began. Yet persistent injury concerns and off-field challenges, including a widely reported incident involving an alleged extortion attempt, complicated this final act. Fans hoping for a revival instead witnessed the continued unraveling of a once-glittering career.

Economic and Cultural Impact

From an economic standpoint, Pogba’s career reflects both the power and the peril of modern football’s branding era. His 2016 transfer not only shattered records but also demonstrated the growing value placed on players as marketable entities. Pogba’s global appeal—combining his athletic prowess with a magnetic personality—helped Manchester United expand its digital presence and commercial partnerships, even during lean sporting seasons.

However, the scrutiny that accompanied his commercial stature also became a vice. Each episode of controversy risked not only reputational but financial fallout, underscoring how inseparable performance and image have become in the era of globalized sports marketing.

On a broader scale, Pogba’s experience illustrates how young Black athletes often navigate contradictory expectations: to be authentic yet conforming, expressive yet humble, marketable yet modest. The tension between these demands can erode even the strongest careers when institutional and media narratives fail to protect individuality.

Legacy and Re-evaluation

As of today, Pogba’s playing future remains uncertain, but his impact on modern football culture is indisputable. For a generation of aspiring midfielders, particularly those from African and European diaspora communities, Pogba represented the possibility of merging artistry with power, elegance with grit.

While his career may not have matched the statistical peaks that define “greatness” by conventional standards, it’s possible his true influence lies elsewhere—in the discourse he provoked and the boundaries of self-expression he widened. His legacy challenges the next era of football culture to reconsider what it values most: conformity or creativity, obedience or authenticity.

The Broader Conversation

The conversation about Pogba transcends one man’s journey. It touches on broader questions about diversity, representation, and fairness in modern sports media. How players are framed, who is extended patience, and whose flaws become defining traits all shape the emotional economy of fandom and the structural biases of the football industry.

For many supporters, Pogba’s story is a reminder that brilliance can coexist with imperfection, that talent can be misunderstood, and that history often treats its outliers more harshly before finally acknowledging their significance. Like many misunderstood geniuses in sport, Pogba’s narrative may only gain clarity—and due appreciation—with time.

Conclusion: The Price of Being Paul Pogba

Paul Pogba’s journey encapsulates the dual nature of football stardom in the digital age: the thrill of global adoration and the isolation of perpetual judgment. His treatment by both critics and fans reflects not only footballing expectations but societal attitudes toward difference, confidence, and identity.

In time, recollections of his dazzling turns, pinpoint passes, and infectious charisma may outweigh the controversies that clouded his career. If history views him with the nuance denied to him in real time, Pogba may yet be recognized not just as one of his generation’s most gifted midfielders, but as one of its most misunderstood.